by Martin Willis
Here is a briefing below that I had generated.
Sources:
- Hearing Wrap Up: Transparency and Accountability Needed to Provide Accurate Information on UAPs to the American People – United States House Committee on Oversight and Accountability
- UFOs and UAPs should be studied by the U.S., experts tell congressional hearing : NPR
Summary:
A joint hearing was held by the House Oversight Committee subcommittees on Cybersecurity, Information Technology, and Government Innovation and National Security, the Border, and Foreign Affairs on November 13, 2024, focusing on Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAPs). The hearing featured testimonies from four experts: Retired Rear Admiral Tim Gallaudet, Author and Former DoD Official Luis Elizondo, Former NASA Associate Administrator Michael Gold, and Journalist Michael Shellenberger.
Key Themes:
- Lack of Transparency and Accountability: The DoD’s lack of transparency regarding UAPs, including undisclosed spending on UAP-related programs and limited information sharing with Congress, was a major point of concern.
- Dr. Tim Gallaudet highlighted the potential constitutional crisis: “the failure of the Executive Branch to share UAP information with Congress is an infringement on the legislative branch that undermines separation powers and may be creating a constitutional crisis.”
- Michael Shellenberger emphasized the Executive Branch’s responsibility: “There is, however, a growing body of evidence that the government is not being transparent about what it knows about unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAP), formerly called UFOs, and that elements within the military and IC are in violation of their Constitutional duty to notify Congress of their operations.”*
- National Security Implications: Concerns were raised about the national security implications of UAP encounters, particularly those occurring near sensitive military installations.
- Rep. Glenn Grothman questioned the prevalence of UAP incursions over military facilities.
- Luis Elizondo acknowledged a “long historical record” of such events and suggested a potential connection to “sensitive U.S. military installations, also some of our nuclear equities, some of our Department of Energy sites.”
- Elizondo expressed concern over UAPs’ ability to “enter into U.S. air space with no attribution.”
- Need for Scientific Study and Open Dialogue: Experts advocated for dedicated research efforts and open discussion on UAPs, overcoming the stigma associated with the topic.
- Michael Gold stressed the need to “overcome the pernicious stigma that continues to impede scientific dialogue and open discussions” and emphasized the potential for new discoveries: “I think probably the vast majority of UAP are drones, experimental aircraft, weather conditions. But there is a percentage that isn’t.”
- Elizondo described UAPs as “an enigma, sir, and a frustration” and highlighted the potential threat posed by advanced technologies exceeding current human capabilities.
- Allegations of Secret UAP Programs: Luis Elizondo asserted the existence of secret government programs focused on retrieving and reverse-engineering crashed UAPs, suggesting the possibility of both private companies and non-human intelligence being involved.
- He confirmed the existence of such programs in response to questioning by Rep. Nancy Mace.
- However, he declined to elaborate further in an open session, citing confidentiality restrictions.
- Whistleblower Report and “Immaculate Constellation”: Michael Shellenberger presented a whistleblower report detailing a highly secretive program named “Immaculate Constellation,” allegedly focused on collecting UAP data.
- The report included an account of an F-22 encounter with multiple UAPs exhibiting advanced capabilities.
- Rep. Mace acknowledged concerns about potential repercussions for mentioning the program’s name publicly.
Important Facts and Findings:
- The hearing underscored the increasing congressional interest and concern surrounding UAPs.
- Witnesses emphasized the need for greater transparency from the DoD and intelligence community.
- Allegations of secret programs and recovered UAP materials remain highly controversial but underscore the need for further investigation.
- The potential national security implications of UAPs, particularly their presence near sensitive military installations, require serious attention.
Recommendations:
- Congress should pursue legislation mandating greater transparency from the executive branch on UAP-related information.
- Dedicated funding should be allocated to scientific research on UAPs, utilizing advanced data collection and analysis methods.
- Open dialogue and collaboration between government agencies, scientists, and the public are crucial to address the UAP phenomenon effectively.
- Further investigation into whistleblower claims and alleged secret programs is warranted.
Overall, the hearing highlighted the growing urgency to address the UAP phenomenon responsibly and transparently. The lack of clear answers and ongoing secrecy contribute to public uncertainty and raise valid concerns about national security and potential technological advancements beyond human capabilities.